A joint project of the Graduate School, Peabody College, and the Jean & Alexander Heard Library

Title page for ETD etd-03202013-130105

Type of Document Dissertation
Author Athay Tomlinson, Mary Michele
Author's Email Address Michele.Athay@Vanderbilt.edu
URN etd-03202013-130105
Title Categorical and Dimensional Presentations of Information in Clinical Feedback: The Role of Cognitive Fit
Degree PhD
Department Psychology
Advisory Committee
Advisor Name Title
Leonard Bickman Committee Chair
James H. Steiger Committee Member
Sun-Joo Cho Committee Member
Thomas M. Smith Committee Member
  • decision-making
  • feedback
  • externalizing symptoms
  • latent variable structure
  • latent class analysis
  • graded response model
Date of Defense 2013-03-18
Availability unrestricted
This dissertation uses cognitive fit to present a novel approach to choosing whether to analyze clinical data assuming a categorical or dimensional latent variable structure. Cross-sectional and longitudinal models assuming a categorical (i.e., latent class analysis model and latent transition analysis model) and dimensional (i.e., graded response model and longitudinal graded response model) latent variable structure were fit to clinical data from clinically referred youth (N = 204). Results found a large overlap in resulting youth predictions across models. Information regarding whether youth improved, deteriorated, or remained the same in terms of symptom severity was similar between latent class and graded response models. However, the presentation and interpretation of information for use in feedback differed: categorical models yielded information about group (qualitative) differences whereas dimensional models yielded information about individual differences in degree (quantitative). Based on cognitive fit, the most effective and efficient clinical-decisions occur when the specific clinical task matches with the information presentation. This match allows for a deliberate and clinically useful choice in model selection for the creation of clinical feedback. Additionally, results from an informal clinical survey investigating information presentation preferences for specific clinical tasks are presented. Clinician preference may indicate the natural fit between task and information presentation. Implications for clinical feedback are discussed and future studies are proposed to explore further the effect of information presentation on clinical decision-making.
  Filename       Size       Approximate Download Time (Hours:Minutes:Seconds) 
 28.8 Modem   56K Modem   ISDN (64 Kb)   ISDN (128 Kb)   Higher-speed Access 
  MAthayTomlinson_FullDissertation_FINAL_032013.pdf 1.36 Mb 00:06:18 00:03:14 00:02:50 00:01:25 00:00:07

Browse All Available ETDs by ( Author | Department )

If you have more questions or technical problems, please Contact LITS.